Vanished & Violent: The Sodder Children & the Molalla Forest Murders

This week on Disturb Me, the gloves are off. One of us digs into the Sodder children—the five kids who vanished from their West Virginia home on Christmas Eve 1945 after a mysterious fire, leaving behind no bodies, no answers, and a grieving family who never stopped searching. The other heads west to Oregon's Molalla Forest, where a string of murders turned a quiet stretch of woods into one of the state's darkest crime scenes.

A missing-children mystery with no closure versus a body count with no mercy. We tell, we torment, and we try to out-creep each other—but this time, you decide who did it best. Listen, then cast your vote for who deserves the win.

Fair warning: sleep may be optional after this one.